Wednesday, August 4, 2010

Predictive Energy Equations: Which One to Use?


Dietetic interns challenge us to keep our practice current. The question of what predictive energy equation to use in clinical practice was a recent example of how our roles as educators linked to our need to keep current. Fraser Health (FH) interns recognized their preceptors had different approaches to calculating estimated energy needs for their patients and wondered how something so core to dietitians’ daily activities could be so varied in practice. A poll of Canadian dietitians and a literature review provided perspectives on the use of predictive energy equations.

Indirect calorimetry (IC) is the ‘gold standard’ for calculating energy requirements. Several barriers prevent routine measurements on patients including lack of a metabolic cart or personnel to operate equipment, and the impracticality of completing repeated measures on every patient who requires an energy calculation. Consequently, dietitians rely on predictive energy equations to estimate patients’ energy needs.

Over 200 predictive energy equations have been published in efforts to accurately predict energy needs (MacDonald and Hildebrandt, 2003; Ireton- Jones, 2005). No equation has consistently proven to be accurate in hospitalized individuals in acute or critical care. Inaccuracies are introduced due to controversy over which weight to use, the limited number of validation studies done, and the homogeneity of reference populations used when establishing the formulae, amongst other variables (Frankenfield et al., 2005; Fabiono et al., 2009; Walker and Heuberger, 2009).

An e-mail poll in October 2009 to members of the Dietitians of Canada (DC) Clinical Nutrition Managers’ Network yielded a list of the equations used by at least one dietitian at each of the 16 responding sites: 13 sites used Harris Benedict (HB); eight used the American College of Chest Physicians’ equation (25kcal/kg); six used Mifflin-St Jeor; five used one of the Ireton-Jones’ equations; and two used one of the Penn State equations. These results were consistent with practices worldwide (HB remains the most frequently-used formula (Fabiono et al., 2009)), and the varied practices that the FH dietetic interns had noticed.

The e-mail poll also yielded information on which weight (actual, ideal, or adjusted) is used in energy calculations. Four sites used actual weight only and 12 sites used either actual or adjusted weight depending on the individual case. Most sites adjusted body weight using a 25% factor (based on a 1984 American Dietetic Association publication as referenced in Krenitsky, 2005). Other sources recommended a 50% factor (Barack et al., 2002; Krenitsky, 2005). The use of adjusted body weight is not well supported (Barack et al., 2002; Ireton-Jones, 2005; Krenitsky, 2005).

The following points summarize the support for the predictive energy equations with graded evidence-for-use in clinical practice:

Harris-Benedict (Harris and Benedict, 1919): Not sufficiently accurate to be used in the critically ill (Grade I evidence) (Frankenfield et al., 2007) Use actual body weight (Walker and Heuberger, 2004; Krenitsky, 2005).

American College of Chest Physicians (Cerra et al., 1997): Use 25-30 kcal/kg actual body weight for the nonobese critically ill (Grade IV and V evidence). Use 11-14 kcal/kg actual body weight or 22-25 kcal/kg ideal body weight for the obese critically ill (Grade III evidence) (McClave et al., 2009).

Mifflin-St Jeor (Mifflin et al., 1990): Best predictor of energy needs in healthy nonobese and obese adults (Frankenfield et al., 2005). Use actual body weight (McClave et al., 2009). Not recommended in the critically ill (Grade V evidence) (Frankenfield et al., 2007).

Ireton Jones et al. (1992): Most accurate in young and obese adults compared to other populations. Insufficient data to reject the equation (Grade III evidence supporting its use) (Frankenfield et al., 2007; Walker and Heuberger, 2009)

Penn State 1998 and 2003 (Frankenfield et al., 2004): May use 1998 equation for obese, critically ill ventilated patients (Frankenfield et al., 2005). May use 2003 equation for nonobese critically ill patients (Walker and Heuberger, 2009) (Grade III evidence) (Frankenfield, et al., 2007; Walker and Heuberger, 2009).

Swinamer (Swinamer et al., 1987): May use for nonobese critically ill patients (Grade III evidence) (Frankenfield, et al, 2007; Walker and Heuberger, 2009).

Even with an accurate predictive equation, obtaining goal intakes is often hindered by delays in establishing feeding access, enteral feed intolerances, and feedings that are held for tests. Our efforts should go toward achieving goal tubefeeding rates and maximizing oral intake regardless of what equation is used. Further, monitoring markers of feeding adequacy including laboratory measures, weight, ventilator weaning, and wound healing allow us to adjust energy goals as appropriate.

Based on the results of our survey and literature review, we can have confidence in reporting to our interns that there is more to learn before setting standards for estimating energy needs in hospital inpatients. We use these teaching moments as opportunities to discuss the concept of evidence-based practice using best available research, clinical expertise, and a patient-focused approach to guide decision-making to provide the best possible patient care.

A summary chart of the origins and evidence on predictive energy equations is available on request.




Contact

Tamar Kafka, RD, MSc
Dietetic Internship Coordinator/Research Dietitian
Fraser Health
New Westminster BC
E: Tamar.Kafka@fraserhealth.ca





845 comments:

«Oldest   ‹Older   801 – 845 of 845
Nailssy said...

It is truly a well-researched content and excellent wording. I got so engaged in this material that I couldn’t wait reading. I am impressed with your work and skill. Thanks

thmaster said...

You can get great discounts, amazing offers, and the best deal on clothing, electronics, kitchen appliances, and many more products in Amazon Upcoming Sale.

Anil said...

very informative and helpful article really awesome content.
Good morning wishing photo

Organic Zero Waste said...

Nice article...Thanks for sharing........Keep posting more.......

Organic grocery store in india


Organic stores in india


Organic grocery online chennai


Organic stores in chennai

lavanya said...

Thanks for sharing such an amazing post. Your style of writing is very unique. It made me mesmerized in your words. Keep on writing. Software Testing Training in Chennai | Software Testing Training in Anna Nagar | Software Testing Training in OMR | Software Testing Training in Porur | Software Testing Training in Tambaram | Software Testing Training in Velachery

Packers And Movers Gurgaon said...

Packers and Movers Gurgaon Provide Reliable, Safe and Certified Service Provider list, Get Free ***Best Price Quotaition and Compare Charges. ???Hassle free Household Shifting Services, High Quality packing Material, Office Relocation, Car Transportaion, ###Local and Domestic Shifting Service @
Packers And Movers Gurgaon

Packers and Movers Hyderabad said...

I do consider all the ideas you have presented on your post. They're really convincing and will certainly work. Packers And Movers Bangalore

Dissertation Writing Services said...

I like your news about predictive energy is used for minimising the consumption of smoke which is becoming a cause of pollution. I appreciate your efforts to take such useful steps.

Packers And Movers Delhi said...

Get Shifting/Relocation Quotation from ###Packers and Movers Delhi. Packers and Movers Delhi 100% Affordable and Reliable ***Household Shifting Services. Compare Transportation Charges and Save Time, Verified and Trusted Packers and Movers in Delhi, Cheap and Safe Local, Domestic House Shifting @ Packers And Movers Delhi

meldaresearch said...

Online psychology essay writing services are very difficult to complete and many students are always searching for Help with Psychology Coursework Writing services to help them complete their psychology research paper writing services and psychology case study writing services.

online store said...

THANKS FOR SHARING NICE ARTICLE

BUY WEED ONLINE

BUY OXYCODONE ONLINE

BUY IBOGAINE ONLINE

BUY DANK VAPE ONLINE

BUY PURPLE QUEEN ONLINE

BUY IBOGAINE CAPSULES ONLINE

BUY SUBUTEX 8MG ONLINE

BUY GELATO DANK VAPE CARTRIDGE ONLINE

Term Paper Writing Services said...

Buy descriptive essay help online seekers has been on the rise lately since most learners need Descriptive Essay Writing Services, descriptive essay writing help and descriptive essay services.

Term Paper Writing Services said...

Online e-commerce essay writing help services are very common nowadays since there are very many students seeking E-commerce Essay Writing Services and e-commerce research paper writing services.

dorcassmith said...

Law Assignment Writing Services are hard to come across for those in need of Law Research Writing Services and law essay writing services.

Hero said...


Thank You for the excellent articles will surely read more of yours...

How to lose weight fast without exercise

Weight Loss Diet Plan

Fat Cutter Drink

Diet Plan for Weight Loss

Veg Diet Plan

Weight Gain Diet Plan

BEST DIET PLAN FOR WEIGHT LOSS

Maxwell said...

I was searching for this post since a long time. Thanks, I found on your website. Nice article.Sharepoint Online Training

EmmaOlivia said...

Thanks for sharing usefull information and I really appreciate your good and hard work as always. Visit Online Jewellery Design

Ekra Decor said...

Ekra Decor Pvt Ltd. is one of the prominent organizations in construction of tensile structure. We design and manufacture all type of permanent and temporary membrane fabric structure since 1998.

Tensile Structure
Tensile Structure in Delhi
Walkway Tensile Structure
Gazebo Tensile Structure
Swimming Pool Tensile Structure
Car Parking Tensile Structure

24x7ambulance said...

AMB life is an online platform that allows private ambulance service carriers around the globe to register their ambulance and other ancillary services on its platform. People can choose services based on country, state, city or even their own location. Both air ambulance as well ground ambulance can be booked based on their rating and review.

Ambulance Number in Guwahati
Ambulance Number in Delhi
Ambulance in Delhi
Ambulance Service in Delhi
Ventilator Ambulance Service in Delhi
Ambulance Service in Lucknow
Ambulance Number in Lucknow
Ventilator Ambulance Service in Lucknow
Ambulance Service from Lucknow to Delhi

Wondermouse Technologies said...

WonderMouse Technology is a Digital marketing company in delhi. We market brands on the web & make sure that you get bang for your buck by SEO, SEM, PPC, SMO, Email Marketing, etc. Internet business is the present and eventual fate of overall exchange. WonderMouse Technology is the pioneer in making Ecommerce a smooth ordeal and top website designing company in Delhi knows it great. The platforms are designed specifically to enhance the consumer panorama of corporate websites. We offer customized and affordable best seo services in india which are designed to the needs, desires and budget of our clients.

Dhanraj said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Dhanraj said...

good info thanks Crpf full form
Wifi full form
Ok full form
Pubg full form
BSF Full Form
NCC Full Form
Phd Full Form
iti full form
rss full form
upsc study

Dhanraj said...

crpf full form
BSF full form
ok full form
Pubg full form
WiFi full form
NCC full form
Phd Full Form
gym Full Form

Anonymous said...

THANKS FOR SHARING NICE ARTICLE

BUY WEED ONLINE

BUY OXYCODONE ONLINE

BUY IBOGAINE ONLINE

BUY DANK VAPE ONLINE

BUY PURPLE QUEEN ONLINE

BUY IBOGAINE CAPSULES ONLINE

BUY SUBUTEX 8MG ONLINE

BUY GELATO DANK VAPE CARTRIDGE ONLINE

BUY SURGICAL FACE MASK IN EUROPE

BUY SURGICAL FACE MASK IN USA

BUY SURGICAL FACE MASK ONLINE

ORDER SURGICAL FACE MASK ONLINE

prashant said...

nice article and informative.alaways post this types of articles.

G-FORCE GAMING said...

nice article and informative.alaways post this types of articles.
thanks

Pralhad mule patil said...

Very very informative blog.I like it. Keep doing it gk for competitive exams

Florahmelda said...

Accounting assignment writing services have become very popular for students studying finance & accounting coursework writing services as they engage the best online Accounting Writing Services.

Anonymous said...

In order to ensure zero plagiarism, great papers writing company applies writing software. The software determines parts of the completed materials that appear in other published work. Subsequently, the company writers and editors conduct corrections until the final paper is completely original.Our "do my assignment" services are original and efficient

jibran said...

Best Fish Finders For The Money 2020
Garmin Striker 4 Built-in GPS Fish Finder, is found to be one of the best fish finder brand GPS. It’s comparatively small with other fish finders but still, it does its job perfectly. Each and everything will be clear to you due to its high colour contrasts and brightness. The good thing about it is you can mark your hot spots to make fish catching easier for you regardless of whether you are in open water or in the lake.
https://bestfishfinderreviewz.com/

jibran said...

Best Fish Finders For The Money 2020
Garmin Striker 4 Built-in GPS Fish Finder, is found to be one of the best fish finder brand GPS. It’s comparatively small with other fish finders but still, it does its job perfectly. Each and everything will be clear to you due to its high colour contrasts and brightness. The good thing about it is you can mark your hot spots to make fish catching easier for you regardless of whether you are in open water or in the lake.
https://bestfishfinderreviewz.com/

jibran said...


Best Spray Tan Solution 2020
A best spray tan solution, is a method of giving you tanned skin for several days, without having to reveal yourself to deadly UV light as you would in a tanning salon or by sunbathing. There are several primary qualities that a tanning solution should have so that you attain natural-looking coverage and a great tanned color that not only shines up your complexion but also persists for a pretty long time .Sunless tanners are available in lotion, gel, spray, powder, and mousse. There are also staged tanners for deeper and longer-lasting results.
http://spraytansolutionreview.com/

jibran said...

Best 6 Volt Golf Cart Batteries In 2020
Batteries are what powers the whole circuit process and are absolutely crucial for the machine, therefore you cannot risk getting a battery for your cart that Is undependable and erratic.Your golf cart is very essential because it is a mode of transportation, which is indeed, If not, the most revolutionary invention of mankind, providing all sorts of benefits including its efficiency and how less time consuming it makes our travels or journeys, and It does so with quite the comfort and ease.
http://bestgolfcartbattery.com/

jibran said...

Best SEO Agency in Pakistan
Digisiz offers complete range of online marketing services including SEO, SMO & PPC. We are working in Italy and Pakistan and had a proven record in the field of Digital Marketing. We have been working in the field of Online Marketing for the last 5 to 6 years. We can help you get better exposure for your products & campaigns. Improve your digital presence positively engage with your community.
https://www.digisiz.com/

siva said...

This information is impressive; I am inspired with your post writing style & how continuously you describe this topic.
After reading your post, thanks for taking the time to discuss this, I feel happy about it and I love learning more about this topic..

Mobile Offers
Today Mobile Offers
Mobile Phones
Mobile Offers In Flipkart
Latest Mobile Offers
Mobile Offers In India
Realme Mobile Offers
Mobile Phones Under 10,000
Amazon Mobile Offers
Flipkart Mobile Offers
Up Coming Mobile Offers


Very detailed and informative!!
Keep On Sharing....

xfgrdxhdxh said...

https://digitalgetnow.xyz/west-ham-vs-chelsea/

https://digitalgetnow.xyz/ufc251live/

Unknown said...

Tüp Mide Ameliyatı Nedir?,Tüp mide ameliyatı, en sık uygulanan mide küçültme cerrahi girişimi olarak bilinmekte ve günümüzde mide küçültmenin en etkili yöntemlerinden birini oluşturmaktadır. Tüp mide ameliyatı; midenin uzun ince bir şekle sokularak %80’lik bölümünün cerrahi olarak çıkarılmasına dayanmaktadır. Tüp mide ameliyatı sırasında, kapalı ameliyat yöntemi (laparoskopi) uygulanmaktadır.

Bu konuda bir uzmandan destek alabilmek için Kordon International sitesine ulaşabilirsiniz.

Term Paper Writing Services said...

There are many custom finance assignment writing services and Finance Coursework Writing Services to choose from for those stuck with their finance case study writing services and finance research paper help services.

Florahmelda said...

Accounting assignment writing services have become very popular for students studying finance & accounting coursework writing services as they engage the best online Accounting Writing Services.

Cheapflightreservations said...

I am impressed by reading your blog because you have deep knowledge about this topic and you can make sure your skills more improved.
United Airlines Official Site is the right place to Book United Airlines Reservations for the people and finding cheap flights deals
United Airlines Reservations
United Airlines Official Site

Way4fly said...

I love to read this content due to the easy readability of this blog. thank you for sharing this blog
Way4Fly is Now Offering Cheap Delta Airlines Reservations rather than Delta Airlines Official Site.

EmmaOlivia said...

Hello my name is Emma & I really thanks to you for great information please see Jewellery Design

watson567 said...

If you like to share your review with The Fresh Market. So you don’t need to go anywhere because you are at the right post.

The Fresh Market

Roman Davis said...

I appreciate your thinking about Energy uses and it's producing because all the types of machinery are working due to energy and we are feeling the need for solar energy to fulfil the requirements.
phd dissertation writing services

hafiz said...

KAMPUS BAGUS

«Oldest ‹Older   801 – 845 of 845   Newer› Newest»