Monday, September 28, 2009

Vitamin B12 Treatment Options: Supplementation vs. Intramuscular Injections

As a dietetic intern, I (AD) had the opportunity to present an inservice to family physicians and allied health professionals on vitamin B12 deficiency in the elderly during my placement at the Grandview Medical Centre Family Health Team (FHT). As I reviewed the literature, I became passionate about the importance of vitamin B12 deficiency diagnosis and treatment in light of the inconsistent diagnostic criteria and various treatment methods. As a result, I feel strongly that we need to raise awareness among health professionals on the need for more rigorous diagnostic criteria, as well as ‘non-traditional’ treatment methods such as oral supplementation versus intramuscular (IM) injections.


The main area of discussion during the inservice was the effectiveness of oral vitamin B12 supplementation compared to IM injections in light of the high prevalence of malabsorption due to the absence of intrinsic factor (IF) in people with pernicious anemia. IM injections have historically been the preferred treatment for vitamin B12 deficiency, bypassing the active absorption mechanism (where vitamin B12 binds to IF in the terminal ileum prior to absorption). However, the mechanism for absorption of vitamin B12 via the oral route is less commonly understood.


Oral vitamin B12 supplementation relies on free vitamin B12 to be absorbed passively without binding to IF. This accounts for 1–2% of total absorption and is unaffected in patients with pernicious anemia, gastro-duodenal surgical resection, and those with low gastric acidity (Cuskelly, Mooney and Young, 2007). Therefore, when pharmacological doses (>1,000μg) are ingested, approximately 1% of vitamin B12 (about 10 μg) is absorbed by passive diffusion exceeding the Dietary Reference Intake (DRI) requirement of 2.4μg/ day for all adults. Numerous randomized controlled trials have revealed oral vitamin B12 supplementation to be equally effective to IM injections for correcting cobalamin (B12) deficiency (Simone et al., 2005; Butler et al., 2006).


Diagnosis of Deficiency

Unfortunately, there remains no ‘gold standard’ diagnostic criteria of vitamin B12 deficiency. The most common measure for deficiency is serum B12, an unreliable and insensitive measure of vitamin B12 status (Gibson, 2005). Efforts are being made to raise the cutoff value for deficiency to effectively capture those with inadequate levels of cobalamin. For instance, at my FHT placement a serum cobalamin <130μg/l>


Because vitamin B12 deficiency is common and symptoms can be vague and similar to those experienced with aging (e.g., loss of appetite, fatigue, paleness and confusion), it can easily go undetected and untreated (Wolters, 2004). The danger of undetected vitamin B12 deficiency leading to mostly irreversible neurological and psychiatric implications emphasizes the importance of clinicians taking a closer look at vitamin B12 levels particularly among patients over the age of 50 years and those with other risk factors. Registered dietitians should recommend oral cobalamin

supplementation for those with low vitamin B12 status (<250μmol/l).


Benefits of Oral Supplementation

A Canadian cost analysis study reported a potential cost savings of $17.6 million per year by switching from IM injections to oral vitamin B12 therapy (van Walraven et al., 2001). Costs savings are attributed to decreased health care labour. Patient benefits of oral therapy include convenience of home therapy and decreased injection-related anxiety and discomfort.


People not suited for oral treatment are those unable to regularly take medications, those with short bowel syndrome, or those who have active bowel disease.


Conclusion

Following my inservice there is increased awareness at the FHT on vitamin B12 deficiency, the importance for more rigorous diagnostic criteria, and greater physician and dietitian confidence in recommending oral vitamin B12 supplementation. Reflecting on this rich learning experience has allowed me to truly appreciate the influence that research has on directing everyday practice.

I (AD) would like to thank my two preceptors, Michelle Saraiva, RD and April Hoover, RD, for their help and guidance in researching this topic and applying the evidence.


REFERENCES available from Michelle Saraiva.



Contact

Grandview Medical Centre Family Health Team
Cambridge, ON

Andrea D'Ambrosio, MAN, BASc
Masters of Applied Nutrition (MAN) Dietetic Intern
E: adambros@uoguelph.ca

Michelle Saravia, RD, MAN
E: msaraiva@gmchft.ca

April Hoover, RD, CDE
E: ahoover@gmcfht.caa

24 comments:

Suzanne said...

Good article

Sara said...

interesting

Claude said...

Great article! Very informative!

Gayathri Murthy said...

Very interesting article!

saraiva.michelle said...

We at Grandview (where the author interned) have been screening more of our patients for B12 deficiency, especailly those taking Metformin. As a result of using the higher cutoff of 250 pmol for interpreting the lab work, we have identified more people with low vit B12 levels and thus have been able to treat them and avoid long term deficiency. Awareness has been key! Other allied health have now been screening patients as well.

Online Pharmacy said...

Thanks for sharing such a rare information. It will help us to create awareness among people about the deficiency of the vitamin. Diagnosis of the deficiency must be done in time otherwise it can be dangerous.

dirlinigritton said...

good get-togethers, parties, or any celebration where kodiaddonstv but it can end up being also better with a few add-ons. great.

ershovayuli said...

good Unlike a DVR provider or virtually all different on-demand go to showboxdownloadz Consequently once you download and mount the BlueStacks iphone app Showbox Download App great.

robertgreene said...

good Let’s have got a search on the step by step teaching open iplaystoredownload.com It is certainly certainly not a modified variant of this request. nice.

Kelly Aniston said...

Hey!
Some friends of mine are using b12 therapy to fight their diseases. Both of them are vegans, and you don't need to be a Sherlock Holmes to multiply two and two. I even hired some writing gurus to describe this correlation for my bachelor degree paper. And it was obvious. So, my point is that you need to think twice of becoming vegan or something like this.

gleason ricardo said...

good This lets programs you've got downloaded from anyplace other as opposed to Vidmate APK The program takes your video viewing experience. Sadly, like many nice.

Jhon said...


good Unlike a DVR provider or virtually all different on-demand
open playstoredownloadfree.co

danny donald said...

thanks for sharing playstoredownloadpc.com

nitin malik said...

click

audreybphillips said...

good Hope you adhered to the procedure and mounted Vidmate Vidmate APK Download I will certainly likewise be taking care of Mac customers best.

audreybphillips said...

Great but additionally on computer, tablet. imo download for pc of the most secured talking application, security Fine.

bettycyoung said...

good We could make use of imo application on apple iphone, Android, iPad systems. imo for windows our imo app download on COMPUTER. Following Go to All apps nice.

cathrynzbrown said...

good The Stories of stars that you have actually additionaled snapchatonlinelogine.com touch with Wi-Fi and then start sharing your image utilizing great.

cathrynzbrown said...

Great a better speed or conserve your data from people. wifikill for pc download apk follow the directions provided below Fine.

Thomas pedro said...

Since most homes are sold, getting away from inevitable dispossession is a thing that has the most astounding need in the agenda. Awful credit home advance renegotiating could be the arrangement that could give truly necessary alleviation to hard-squeezed property holders. Payday Loans San-diego

Thomas pedro said...

These advances are anything but difficult to renegotiate, as they can be paid in simple regularly scheduled payments. Little portions separated over a time of a couple of years are anything but difficult to make. Cash Advance

Thomas pedro said...

However, in the event that the mortgage holder can't make a house installment, there is no cash for the moneylender, duh! Mr. Moneylender what about half of something versus 100% of nothing. Yet, the moneylender wouldn't like to trust itPayday Loans Corona

virginiaddavis45kn@gmail.com said...

good modify your very own music and also lip-syncing Musical.ly APK Download for Android | An Ultimate Guide video clips with friends so constantly describe nice.

virginiaddavis said...

good then allow us share every little thing about it. TuTuApp is tutuapp some of the fashionable apps as well as games great.