Monday, September 28, 2009

Vitamin B12 Treatment Options: Supplementation vs. Intramuscular Injections

As a dietetic intern, I (AD) had the opportunity to present an inservice to family physicians and allied health professionals on vitamin B12 deficiency in the elderly during my placement at the Grandview Medical Centre Family Health Team (FHT). As I reviewed the literature, I became passionate about the importance of vitamin B12 deficiency diagnosis and treatment in light of the inconsistent diagnostic criteria and various treatment methods. As a result, I feel strongly that we need to raise awareness among health professionals on the need for more rigorous diagnostic criteria, as well as ‘non-traditional’ treatment methods such as oral supplementation versus intramuscular (IM) injections.


The main area of discussion during the inservice was the effectiveness of oral vitamin B12 supplementation compared to IM injections in light of the high prevalence of malabsorption due to the absence of intrinsic factor (IF) in people with pernicious anemia. IM injections have historically been the preferred treatment for vitamin B12 deficiency, bypassing the active absorption mechanism (where vitamin B12 binds to IF in the terminal ileum prior to absorption). However, the mechanism for absorption of vitamin B12 via the oral route is less commonly understood.


Oral vitamin B12 supplementation relies on free vitamin B12 to be absorbed passively without binding to IF. This accounts for 1–2% of total absorption and is unaffected in patients with pernicious anemia, gastro-duodenal surgical resection, and those with low gastric acidity (Cuskelly, Mooney and Young, 2007). Therefore, when pharmacological doses (>1,000μg) are ingested, approximately 1% of vitamin B12 (about 10 μg) is absorbed by passive diffusion exceeding the Dietary Reference Intake (DRI) requirement of 2.4μg/ day for all adults. Numerous randomized controlled trials have revealed oral vitamin B12 supplementation to be equally effective to IM injections for correcting cobalamin (B12) deficiency (Simone et al., 2005; Butler et al., 2006).


Diagnosis of Deficiency

Unfortunately, there remains no ‘gold standard’ diagnostic criteria of vitamin B12 deficiency. The most common measure for deficiency is serum B12, an unreliable and insensitive measure of vitamin B12 status (Gibson, 2005). Efforts are being made to raise the cutoff value for deficiency to effectively capture those with inadequate levels of cobalamin. For instance, at my FHT placement a serum cobalamin <130μg/l>


Because vitamin B12 deficiency is common and symptoms can be vague and similar to those experienced with aging (e.g., loss of appetite, fatigue, paleness and confusion), it can easily go undetected and untreated (Wolters, 2004). The danger of undetected vitamin B12 deficiency leading to mostly irreversible neurological and psychiatric implications emphasizes the importance of clinicians taking a closer look at vitamin B12 levels particularly among patients over the age of 50 years and those with other risk factors. Registered dietitians should recommend oral cobalamin

supplementation for those with low vitamin B12 status (<250μmol/l).


Benefits of Oral Supplementation

A Canadian cost analysis study reported a potential cost savings of $17.6 million per year by switching from IM injections to oral vitamin B12 therapy (van Walraven et al., 2001). Costs savings are attributed to decreased health care labour. Patient benefits of oral therapy include convenience of home therapy and decreased injection-related anxiety and discomfort.


People not suited for oral treatment are those unable to regularly take medications, those with short bowel syndrome, or those who have active bowel disease.


Conclusion

Following my inservice there is increased awareness at the FHT on vitamin B12 deficiency, the importance for more rigorous diagnostic criteria, and greater physician and dietitian confidence in recommending oral vitamin B12 supplementation. Reflecting on this rich learning experience has allowed me to truly appreciate the influence that research has on directing everyday practice.

I (AD) would like to thank my two preceptors, Michelle Saraiva, RD and April Hoover, RD, for their help and guidance in researching this topic and applying the evidence.


REFERENCES available from Michelle Saraiva.



Contact

Grandview Medical Centre Family Health Team
Cambridge, ON

Andrea D'Ambrosio, MAN, BASc
Masters of Applied Nutrition (MAN) Dietetic Intern
E: adambros@uoguelph.ca

Michelle Saravia, RD, MAN
E: msaraiva@gmchft.ca

April Hoover, RD, CDE
E: ahoover@gmcfht.caa

428 comments:

«Oldest   ‹Older   401 – 428 of 428
lottery sambad said...

Great post by this website Visit us at
Dhankesari

Govt.job Alert said...

Rajasthan Computer Teacher Recruitment
Rajuvas Animal Husbandry Veterinary Two year Deploma

get web series said...

Get web series - Trending Indian Web Series News & Info

Get webseries is an entertainment site. you will get Trending Indian web series and Hollywood web series news & information.

Santosh Das said...

Thanks for sharing such a lovely information with us. Want to download minifast Blogger Template for your blog. Download from above link.

Raymond Senecal said...

The writer of Spouts: the whale who saved Christmas can give you a glimpse of the tropical islands and South Seas with the adventure to the Hula Bear Island in the book. We at Eden Bancrofts have a wide range of books available at a cost-effective pricing range. Visit our website for more details.

otherwhatsapp said...

Muito feliz em ler esse compartilhamento significativo, obrigado por compartilhar, se você estiver interessado, descubra coisas mais úteis em https://otherwhatsapp.com/

Santosh Das said...

Thanks for sharing such lovely information with us. Want to download Bike Background Images for your blog.

William Smith said...

The blog written is extremely impressive, with a great topic. However, a bit more research could have strengthened it even further. You can explore the services as offered by livewebtutors.com, a premium academic writing services platform offering the best of Assignment help teamed with knowledge and experience

سحاب said...

متخصص سئو 
سئوکار حرفه ای
مشاوره سئو
بهترین سئوکار ایران
مدیر سئو
سئو
خدمات سئو
صفحه اول گوگل
آموزش سئو

nasirnoel11 said...

Sweet Peppers Deli is an American casual dining restaurant chain famous for serving BBQ Chicken Flatbread and other foods. It was founded by Bean family and now it has around 6 locations in Alabama, Georgia, and Mississippi.SweetPeppersDeli


hacijy567 said...

You will get each and every single essential information regarding this Jason’s Deli Customer Experience Survey better known as JasonsDeliFeedback from this post so keep reading this post.

JasonsDeliFeedback

Shayari Night said...

Webocity is website designing company in delhi , Best Website development company in Delhi, We Offer Best Digital Marketing services in Delhi.

Maryann Nichols said...

At Impact Auto Glass, we make sure to deliver exceptional work and services with the help of Professional Auto Technicians in Longwood FL. We are a leading automotive company working to meet the needs of the customers. Make sure to visit our website to find detailed information about our services.

gaby said...

CHECK THIS

Buzz News Post, Buzz News Post, press las vegas, Las Vegas News, United News Post, United News Post, star news express, star news express

Lucy Albritton said...

Need a comfortable and technically equipped facemask to keep you safe from the COVID-19? Delivering the Best Face Masks Manufactured in USA, we at I Mask Plus LLC are inspired to improve the quality to become the best in the market. Make sure to visit our website for more details.

Mark said...

Today News Post
best soundcloud Downloader
best youtube downloader
ok ru downloader
vk downloader
pinterest video downloader

Anonymous said...

Model Paper 2021
AP TET Notification 2021
Bihar Board 12th Result 2021
Check JAMB Result 2021
Maharashtra 12th Question Paper 2021

DigiSpell035 said...

soundcloud to mp3
Tiktok Video Downloader
pinterest video downloader
reddit video downloader
twitch clip downloader
bandcamp downloader
twitter video downloader

alsha cafe said...

I hope that all kinds of information will help you to complete the Cash Store Guest Satisfaction Survey.

cashstore

Tekniko Global said...

Tekniko Global is an app development company in delhi. We have core expert for iOS app & Android application development. We provide Custom App development services at reasonable cost.

Rahul said...

Why Rotary Unions Shouldn’t Be Seen as ‘Just a Commodity’?
DON'T USE A NEEDLE VALVE TO CONTROL YOUR AIR CYLINDER SPEED!
It's FRL Unit on Purpose, Folks!
Directional Control Valves
Elements Used For The Air Preparation In The Pneumatic System

What Are Directional Control Valves, And Why Do You Need One?
Poppet Directional Control Valves
"
HOW TO ACHIEVE ULTIMATE PNEUMATIC TOOL PERFORMANCE BY OPTIMIZING AIR LINE INSTALLATION
"
What You Need to Know About Airmax Cylinders
The Ultimate Guidebook to Rotary Joints & Unions

DigiSpell035 said...

Soundcloud to mp3

Reddit Video Downloader
Twitch Clip Downloader
Youtube to mp3
Tiktok downloader
vimeo to mp4
download tumblr video
bandcamp downloader
Twitter video downloader

Reddit Video Downloader

Best Assignment Help said...

Thanks for sharing this information. I have shared this link with others to keep posting such information to provide the best in class assignment help online at very affordable prices.
Marketing Assignment Help
Math Homework Help
Nursing Assignment Help
programming assignment help
statistics homework help
Finance Homework Help
Business Plan Help

call tutors said...


If you want to know how to create an assignment in google classroom. Here know 4 best tips on how to create an assignment in Google classroom.
How To Create An Assignment In Google Classroom


Assignment reports are difficult to work with, but now you do not have to worry at all. Here are 8 Best Steps On How To Write An Assignment Report in detail
How to Write An Assignment Report

call tutors said...

Find Best management dissertation topic which has never been written so If you are confused about how to start your writing check here
Management Dissertation Topic


Learn how to choose the best topics for accounting research paper that will show your acquired skills and knowledge most effectively.
Topics for Accounting Research Paper

statanalytica said...

Do you want to start with the data science, but don't know how to start? If yes, then here are some basics of statistics for data science to start with.
statistics for data science


Have a look at the best ever comparison between R vs python. Here you will come to know which one is best for data science.
r vs Python

maryammiahan said...

Very informative blog, and beautifully elaborating the complete information about the topic. We are from the same domain emerging as the top mobile app development company for versatile app creation services. You can email us at sales@appsquadz.com or Phone Number: +91-9717270746

Mussawir said...

Thanks for this post. I am currently starting up a blog for our company and I found it to be very helpful! Achasoda

«Oldest ‹Older   401 – 428 of 428   Newer› Newest»